Filter Comparison
| Brand | Aquasana | Amway | Culligan | Kenmore | Seagul | Brita | Brita |
| Model Number |
AQ-4000 | E-5199 | SY-2300 | Deluxe 38465 |
IV X-1 |
Faucet Filter |
Pitcher Filter |
| Retail Price |
$124.99 | $420.00 | $159.99 | $149.99 | $420.00 | $34.95 | $24.95 |
| Replacement Cartridge |
$45.00/ 500 gal. |
$120.00/
1250 gal. |
$50.39/ 500 gal. |
$49.00/ 500 gal. |
$69.99/ 1000 gal. |
$20.00/ 100 gal. |
$7.70/ 30 gal. |
| Per Gallon Cost |
9¢/ gal. |
9.6¢/ gal. |
10¢/ gal. |
9.8¢/ gal. |
7¢/ gal. |
20¢/ gal. |
25¢/ gal. |
| Removes Chlorine | YES >99% |
YES 97.9% |
YES 97% |
YES 99% |
YES >75% |
YES 99% |
YES >75% |
| Removes Lead | YES >99% |
YES 98% |
YES 95% |
YES 92% |
NO | YES 99% |
YES 93% |
| Removes Cysts | YES >99.99% |
YES 99.5% |
YES 99% |
NO | YES >99% |
YES 99.99% |
NO |
| Removes THMs | YES >99% |
YES >99% |
YES 95% |
YES 99% |
NO | NO | NO |
| Removes VOCs | YES >99% |
YES >99% |
YES 95% |
YES 95% |
NO | NO | NO |
| Removes Lindane | YES >99% |
YES 72.7% |
YES 99% |
YES 99% |
NO | YES 99% |
NO |
| Removes Alachlor | YES >98% |
YES 95% |
YES 98% |
YES 95% |
NO | YES 99% |
NO |
| Removes Atrizine | YES >97% |
YES >97% |
YES 97% |
YES 97% |
NO | YES 92% |
NO |
| Removes Benzene | YES >99% |
YES >97% |
YES 99% |
YES 83% |
NO | YES 96% |
NO |
| Removes TCE | YES >99% |
YES >98% |
YES 99% |
YES 98% |
YES >99% |
YES 99% |
NO |
| Removes MTBE | YES >93% |
NO | YES 90% |
NO | NO | NO | NO |
| Total Cost For 1 Year/1000 gal. |
$164.95 | $420.00 | $210.38 | $198.99 | $489.99 | $214.95 | $273.91 |
|
Comparing Water Filters – Most Common Things To Look For:
Lead‚ Volatile Organic Chemicals (VOCs)‚ Organic Contaminants‚ and Disinfection By-Products (THMs‚ Trihalomethanes) are the most noticeable problems on these reports. Often these toxic chemicals exceed the MCLGs or healthful thresholds. Also, these thresholds are relevant only to the one contaminant; if more than one contaminant is present, the thresholds for heath risks drop considerably. All performance claims and pricing were taken from the manufacturer’s literature and certified claims. |
